Fried Pickles and Comeback Sauce: Your How to Guide

Fried Pickles and Comeback Sauce: Your How to Guide

Nothin’ says old South like fried food and a basket of fried pickles with a bowl of spicy sauce sayin’ come and get it!

When you are hankerin’ for some Southern barbecue, are you really craving that super-sauced shredded pork sandwich, or all the fixin’s that go alongside?  Which comes first, the bite of sandwich or chunk of fried potato? For me, it’s all about the starters, and nothing gets me started like a big old basket of fried pickles with a bowlful of spicy comeback sauce, which gets its name from Jackson, Mississippi, where it was created.

There are a bunch of ways to create the batter for the pickles. I like the combination of seasoned flour and buttermilk for a tangy topping. You can use any pickles and fry them whole or cut them into slices. I like to cut whole pickles into diagonal slices giving a two-bite serving. You can use dill pickles or sweet pickles or sweet and spicy pickles. I like good old-fashioned dill pickles right from the jar. You can fry them in vegetable oil or peanut oil. I have vegetable in my pantry, so that’s the way I roll. For the sauce, you can choose your favorite combo, but I like comeback sauce which is similar (although simpler) to remoulade sauce.

Whichever way you fry your pickle, you and your pals are sure to enjoy the results!


Fried Pickles

With Comeback Sauce

serves a crowd

30 minute cuisine

For Pickles:

1 large jar whole dill pickles, drained

½ cup all-purpose flour

1 teaspoon Italian seasoning

1 teaspoon garlic powder

1 teaspoon kosher salt

½ teaspoon coarse black pepper

½ cup buttermilk

Vegetable (or peanut) oil for frying

For Sauce:

½ cup mayonnaise

2 tablespoons chili sauce

2 tablespoons hot pepper sauce

1 tablespoon Worcestershire sauce

1 teaspoon garlic powder

½ teaspoon kosher salt

Cut the pickles into ¼-inch thick diagonal slices. Place the slices onto a baking sheet lined with paper toweling. Use additional paper toweling to dry the pickles slices thoroughly. Place the pickles into the fridge while you stir together the sauce.

Whisk together the sauce ingredients in a small bowl.

Place the flour, Italian seasoning, garlic powder, 1 teaspoon salt and pepper in a bowl. Stir in the buttermilk. The batter will be thick.

Heat vegetable oil in a fryer or deep pan over high heat. You want enough oil to only come up ⅓ of the side of the pan. Dip one pickle slice into the batter. Shake off excess and carefully place in the hot oil. Repeat with several pickle slices. Do not overcrowd the pan. Use a slotted spoon to turn the pickles slices over once they are golden on one side, about 1 to 2 minutes total frying time per slice. Remove the slices to a baking sheet lined with paper toweling. Continue until all of the pickle slices are fried. Serve the warm pickles with the sauce for dipping.


Table of Contents

More Yum

What's New

Plan A Bridgerton-Themed Picnic Party

Host a charming outdoor picnic party with a touch of Bridgerton elegance! Discover Jorj’s top picnic menu recipes and delightful outdoor decor to elevate your gathering to new levels of sophistication.

The Best Dude Food For Dad’s Day

Elevate Father’s Day dining with a simple and delectable dish for Dad. Find product suggestions, serving ideas, and a tutorial video to help you serve the PERFECT meal!

How To Meal Prep, Jorj’s Way!

Elevate meal prep with expert tips and kitchen organization ideas! Try this delicious chicken ravioli recipe and find new ways to maximize your meals, Jorj’s way.

Try Jorj’s Best Potato Recipes

Discover the versatility of the beloved spud in various delectable dishes, from crispy fries to creamy casseroles. Explore new ways to cook and enjoy potatoes!

Scroll to Top